“A lot of the work that I do is historic-the maximum sentences change at different points of time. It's really complicated and people get it wrong all the time. That's when having a timeline is really useful.”
1 High PavementAccess all documents on Bailment
The evolution of the classification of digital assets as property As the cryptocurrency (crypto) sector has matured over the last decade, digital assets of every stripe have accrued significant economic worth and have, inevitably, become the focus of numerous disputes before national courts and arbitral tribunals across the common law world and beyond. Although a substantial volume of interim applications has appeared in jurisdictions such as England & Wales, Singapore, Australia and New Zealand, few – if any – contested proceedings have reached conclusion to date. The causes of that pattern are not entirely germane to this note, save to observe that a recurring feature in a high share of digital asset matters is fraud and/or hacking committed by unidentified and/or unreachable actors, which has, in turn, left cases yielding final determinations thinner on the ground than would be ideal in a highly technical sphere carrying wide-ranging consequences for many branches of the law. Perhaps nothing is more critical than the question of how to legally categorise digital assets...
Armstead v Royal Sun Alliance Insurance Company Ltd [2022] EWCA Civ 497 What are the practical implications of this case? The Court of Appeal considered how far a tortfeasor is responsible in bailment and tort for an owner’s loss of use where hired equipment is damaged, in proceedings brought by the hirer. It ruled that, although a bailee may reclaim the cost of repairing the hired equipment from a negligent tortfeasor, the bailee cannot recover sums fixed by contract with the bailor (the hire company) for the bailor’s loss of use. Because the item involved was a car hired under a credit hire insurance policy, the decision is naturally pertinent to vehicle hire arrangements in general and to credit hire insurance claims in particular. Yet the principles explored, applied and developed in the judgment, particularly on pure economic loss and the scope of the duty of care, are of broader relevance, including to circumstances where liquidated damages provisions and increased or accelerated payment terms are triggered when property is...
Original news Tongue v Royal Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals and another [2017] EWHC 2508 (Ch), [2017] All ER (D) 81 (Oct) No relationship of bailment was formed between the first respondent, the RSPCA, and the appellant, T, when T allowed the RSPCA to go onto the land to look after the cattle following T’s convictions for causing the herd unnecessary suffering. As a result, the RSPCA did not assume a duty of care to T regarding the safeguarding of the cattle, nor did it acquire any corresponding entitlement to recover its expenditure from T... What was the background to this case? This was an unusually troubling and distressing matter. Mr Tongue was a farmer with a sizeable landholding, yet a persistent offender under the Protection of Animals Act 1911, having been found guilty on numerous occasions of inflicting unnecessary suffering on animals. At the relevant time, he had been permanently disqualified from having custody of livestock and faced additional convictions for breaching that...
Practice Note This Practice Note consists of two strands created to help dispute resolution practitioners remain up to date with developments in case law that affect their field, or which influence civil litigation procedure more generally: selected forthcoming appeals to the Supreme Court are highlighted below; see Key forthcoming appeals to the Supreme Court—2022 summaries of significant appeal decisions in England and Wales (ie rulings of the Court of Appeal and Supreme Court and, where appropriate, certain judgments of the Competition Appeal Tribunal, Judicial Committee of the Privy Council, Court of Justice of the European Union), and ECtHR, which we have covered; see: Key forthcoming appeal cases—2022 You can navigate this content using the table of contents in the left-hand margin. Alternatively, search this tracker using [CTRL]+[F]. This material is not intended to be a comprehensive register of every appeal or major decision relevant to dispute resolution practitioners. Key forthcoming appeals to the Supreme Court—2022 Tort and negligence ...
Questions about bailment frequently surface within the art sphere. For instance, warehousing or freight operators may owe bailment obligations when holding and/or moving artworks or other chattels. Lending pieces and/or using artworks as security or collateral can also create bailment relationships. Claims founded on breach of contract and/or negligence often additionally plead bailment. Further illustrations appear throughout this Practice Note. Bailment is a nuanced field. This Practice Note concentrates on bailment issues in the context of art law. For a fuller outline of bailment law generally, see Practice Note: Bailment. See also Q&A: How are damages quantified when bailed goods have been negligently lost? For a summary of aspects of art law pertinent to Private Client practitioners, see Practice Note: Art law-introduction for Private Client practitioners. Additional examples are set out across this Practice Note. What is bailment? Put simply, a bailment may arise at common law where one party assumes temporary possession of another party’s goods, for example: a collector, the bailor, delivers an...
Introduction to the art market and art law Over the past three decades, the art market has altered markedly: Key hubs are now London, New York and Hong Kong, with Paris the fourth largest centre, and domestic markets serving lower-priced art and collectables Transactions have grown more opaque and anonymous Values for iconic works have soared-Leonardo da Vinci’s Salvator Mundi achieved $450.3m in 2017 Leading auction houses exert ever greater power Collectors engage art advisers for due diligence, access and guidance, though some are not suitably qualified The past 20 years have seen the rise of ‘mega’ art fairs, appearing roughly every four months worldwide Art is increasingly treated as an asset class-and promoted as an investment by auction classes In an ever more global market, lawyers acting for collectors, businesses and not-for-profit organisations often encounter multi-jurisdictional matters Rapid developments in AI now encompass AI-generated artwork There is growing acceptance that art law has emerged...