Powered by Lexis+®
Jurisdiction(s):
United Kingdom
CASE STUDY

“I'm able to do more in the day, which means I'm providing more value to my clients - and it's helped my margins in terms of how much I can bill. LexisNexis is helping me make money.”

ParrisWhittaker

Access all documents on Gratuitous alienation

Gratuitous alienation meaning

What does Gratuitous alienation mean?
In Scottish insolvency practice, a gratuitous alienation is a transfer or disposal of assets by a debtor for no consideration or for significantly less than market value before insolvency, which can be challenged and set aside. It is a statutory concept: for companies under the Insolvency Act 1986 (Scotland) and for individuals under the Bankruptcy (Scotland) Act 2016. Typical applications include undoing pre-insolvency gifts or intra‑group transfers. An insolvency office-holder (liquidator, administrator or trustee in sequestration) may seek reduction of the transfer and restoration or compensation. Key features include a look‑back period: for companies, two years where the recipient is not connected and five years where the recipient is an associate/connected person (including associated companies); for individuals, five years. Statutory defences differ from the England & Wales “transaction at an undervalue” regime and may include showing adequate consideration, implementation of a prior obligation, or that the debtor was solvent immediately after the transfer. The expression is specific to Scots law. The closest equivalents are transactions at an undervalue in England & Wales and Northern Ireland; Ireland has analogous avoidance provisions though the terminology differs. The practical significance is high in corporate reorganisations, dividends in specie and asset movements within groups.
Speed up all aspects of your legal work with tools that help you to work faster and smarter. Win cases, close deals and grow your business–all whilst saving time and reducing risk.

View the related Practice Notes about Gratuitous alienation

PRACTICE NOTES
Scotland: Corporate unfair preferences and gratuitous alienations (Insolvency Act 1986 ss 242–243)—hardening periods, statutory/common law challenges, defences, standing and remedies; key case law including Carnbroe

Sections 242 and 243 of the Insolvency Act 1986 (IA 1986) In Scotland, these provisions regulate the two principal forms of antecedent transaction that a company may undertake. They do not apply to individuals or to companies registered in England and Wales; for the position in England, refer to the Practice Notes on transactions at an undervalue under section 238 and on preferences under section 239 of the Insolvency Act 1986. For Scottish individual/personal debtors, consult the Practice Note on gratuitous alienations by individual debtors. For a glossary of frequently used Scottish insolvency terminology, see Practice Note: Glossary of Scottish insolvency words and expressions. Unfair preferences What constitutes an unfair preference? An unfair preference is any transaction entered into by a company, whether before or after 1 April 1986, that has the effect of giving one creditor priority over the general body of creditors (IA 1986, s 243(1)). The date on which the unfair preference arises is the date the transaction became effectual. Hardening periods...

Read More Right Arrow
PRACTICE NOTES
Glossary of Scottish Insolvency Law Terms with England and Wales Equivalents

This is a glossary of common words and expressions used in Scottish insolvency law with the nearest England and Wales insolvency law equivalent (where relevant) Absolute insolvency Meaning: When a person’s liabilities are greater than the overall worth of their assets. Nearest English equivalent: Balance sheet insolvency. Accountant in Bankruptcy (AiB) Meaning: A Scottish Government agency overseeing the regulation of personal bankruptcy (sequestration and Protected Trust Deeds) in Scotland, and able to serve as trustee in sequestrations where no insolvency practitioner is appointed. It also maintains records of corporate insolvencies in Scotland (receivership and liquidations only) but does not perform the role of Official Receiver. See Practice Note: Scotland: the Accountant in Bankruptcy. Nearest English equivalent: N/A. Accountant of Court Meaning: A court-appointed officer within Scottish Courts and Tribunals who administers funds consigned to the Accountant of Court pursuant to a Court of Session interlocutor or during liquidation proceedings. They oversee Judicial Factors or Administrators appointed by the Court to manage estates...

Read More Right Arrow
PRACTICE NOTES
Gratuitous Alienation and Transactions at an Undervalue in Scotland: Risks, Defences and Remedies in Pre-insolvency Property Deals

Background One of the core tenets of an effective insolvency regime is that an insolvency practitioner (described in this Practice Note as an ‘IP’) may examine the conduct of the insolvent party (described in this Practice Note as the ‘Debtor’) in the period preceding insolvency, to determine whether earlier transactions have improperly disadvantaged the valid claims of creditors by reason of antecedent dealings. For instance, a Debtor facing financial distress might have disposed of particular assets at undervalue to generate quick cash in the short term. Yet, by doing so (and effectively placing those assets beyond creditors’ reach) the Debtor may have weakened creditors’ prospects of recovery and nullified any security they held over those assets (for example, a floating charge), rendering it redundant. Although an IP will, for the most part, be focussed on a snapshot of the Debtor’s assets and liabilities at the time of appointment with a view to distributing to creditors, the entitlement to review and potentially recover assets transferred pre-appointment can, in parallel, be...

Read More Right Arrow