A proposed UK income tax charge intended to claw back higher‑rate pensions tax relief from high‑income individuals by imposing a charge on the “excess relief” obtained on pension contributions. The expression was used in draft legislation in the Finance Act 2010 as part of the previous government’s plan to restrict pensions tax relief from 2011–12. Related anti‑forestalling rules (introduced in 2009 and, from April 2010, extended to those with income of £130,000 or more) sought to prevent individuals accelerating contributions ahead of the restriction.
The incoming Coalition government in June 2010 decided not to proceed with the High Income Excess Relief Charge and repealed the unused provisions. Instead, from 6 April 2011 the policy aim was achieved by reducing the pensions annual allowance (with a tapered annual allowance for high earners introduced from 2016).
In practice, the term now arises only in historic pensions tax advice, due diligence, and analysis of the 2009–2011 anti‑forestalling period. Usage is consistent across England & Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland as a UK tax concept. It has no direct application in Ireland, where no equivalent “High Income Excess Relief Charge” existed.