Powered by Lexis+®
CASE STUDY

“LexisNexis is great as I can find the answers I am looking for really quickly. I believe that nothing should be more than 6 clicks away - and the products from LexisNexis deliver on this standard”

Avensure

Access all documents on Smith v Manchester award

Smith v Manchester award meaning

What does Smith v Manchester award mean?
A lump-sum award of damages to compensate an injured claimant for reduced earning capacity—their handicap on the labour market—even if they are working at trial with no immediate wage loss. The term comes from case law (Smith v Manchester Corporation, 1974) and is not defined by statute. Key features: - Addresses the real risk of future disadvantage, such as loss of job security, reduced competitiveness, or needing lower-paid work. - Distinct from a conventional future loss of earnings claim calculated by multiplier/multiplicand, and from a Blamire award (a global figure used where future loss is proved but evidence is uncertain). - Assessed broadly and pragmatically, often by reference to a period of net earnings, taking into account age, skills, residual disability, employment history, and local labour market conditions. - Must avoid double recovery with other heads of loss. Typical in personal injury, employers’ liability and clinical negligence claims where injury leaves a lasting vulnerability. Usage and principles are broadly consistent across England & Wales and Northern Ireland (deriving from the same case law). Scotland applies an equivalent approach to loss of employability and often uses the Smith v Manchester terminology. In Ireland, courts compensate for loss of earning capacity on similar principles, though terminology may vary.
Speed up all aspects of your legal work with tools that help you to work faster and smarter. Win cases, close deals and grow your business–all whilst saving time and reducing risk.

View the related Practice Notes about Smith v Manchester award

PRACTICE NOTES
Practical guidance on Smith v Manchester awards: risk assessment, valuation, evidence, Ogden Tables methodology, and distinction from Blamire awards in personal injury claims

The nature of the award Where an injured person faces a handicap in the labour market because of a lingering disability caused by their injury, they can seek a head of loss commonly known as a Smith v Manchester award, taking its name from the case that popularised the claim. A Smith v Manchester award is sometimes characterised as compensation for reduced earning capacity. Following an injury, a claimant might resume their previous role on identical pay, or comparable employment on equal or higher wages. In such situations there may appear to be no immediate deficit, yet the claimant could, in fact, still be disadvantaged later; for instance, if they lose their current job, they may struggle to secure employment. A conspicuous eye or hand impairment may invite discrimination, or they may require absences for a painful back or forthcoming surgery. A Smith v Manchester award is ordinarily granted as a separate lump sum. It recognises the risk that future earning prospects are impaired despite current employment continuing on...

Read More Right Arrow
PRACTICE NOTES
Personal injury general damages beyond PSLA: Smith v Manchester awards, loss of congenial employment, loss of use, ruined holidays, relationship damage, aggravated damages, unnecessary medical treatment

General damages General damages encompass non-pecuniary heads of loss, both past and future, which resist exact computation; instead, an appropriate sum is assessed by judgment. In everyday parlance, the expression general damages is often used solely for the award covering pain, suffering and loss of amenity (PSLA), and although this is the most usual head within general damages, it is not the only category. Accordingly, particular care should be taken to ensure both parties involved fully understand precisely what is meant at any given point, especially during the course of settlement negotiations, where clarity about the precise scope is essential. For a more complete explanation, see Practice Note: Common recoverable losses in personal injury cases—What are general damages and special damages?...

Read More Right Arrow