Powered by Lexis+®
Jurisdiction(s):
United Kingdom
CASE STUDY

“The forms and precedents section is essential so that I can quickly and easily look up provisions to include in templates or bespoke project contracts.”

RWE

Access all documents on Train of enquiry

Train of enquiry meaning

What does Train of enquiry mean?
A descriptive label for documents that do not themselves directly prove or disprove an issue but which may, on investigation, lead to other material that advances a party’s case or harms an opponent’s. The phrase comes from case law, notably Compagnie Financiere et Commerciale du Pacifique v Peruvian Guano (1882) 11 QBD 55 at 63, which set out the historically wide test of relevance for civil discovery. England and Wales: the “train of enquiry” test is no longer the measure for disclosure. Under CPR 31.6 and the Business and Property Courts disclosure regime (PD 57AD), parties disclose documents they rely on or which support or adversely affect a pleaded case; documents merely leading to a line of enquiry are not normally disclosable unless specifically ordered. Scotland: recovery is by commission and diligence on a properly framed specification of documents; the courts reject “fishing” requests. “Train of enquiry” is not a Scots law test. Northern Ireland: discovery under Order 24 retains the broader Peruvian Guano approach, subject to case management and proportionality. Ireland: discovery turns on relevance and necessity; courts have moved away from Peruvian Guano’s expansive train‑of‑enquiry discovery and will refuse speculative or burdensome requests. Today, the term chiefly contrasts older, wider...
Speed up all aspects of your legal work with tools that help you to work faster and smarter. Win cases, close deals and grow your business–all whilst saving time and reducing risk.

View the related Practice Notes about Train of enquiry

PRACTICE NOTES
FCA Consumer Duty for UK Asset Managers: scope, distribution chains, material influence, exemptions, cross-cutting rules, four outcomes, vulnerable customers, governance and monitoring

This Practice Note This Practice Note explores the implications of the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA)’s Consumer Duty (Duty) for FCA authorised firms holding permissions to: (i) manage an alternative investment fund (AIF); (ii) manage an undertaking for collective investment in transferable securities (UCITS); or (iii) manage investments. It focuses on the key components of the Duty, such as its scope and application (including relevant exclusions, the concept of material influence, and proportional application), the overarching Consumer Duty principle, the cross-cutting rules, and the four outcomes as they pertain to asset management firms. For a summary of the core features of the Consumer Duty with broader application, see Practice Note: The FCA Consumer Duty—essentials. The Duty took effect for new and existing products and services that remained open to sale (or renewal) from 31 July 2023, and for closed book products and services on 31 July 2024. Significant developments are in train. In response to the government’s Financial Services Growth and Competitiveness Strategy, the FCA has set out steps intended...

Read More Right Arrow
PRACTICE NOTES
Practical guidance on CPR 31 standard disclosure (England and Wales): relevance, reasonable search (including electronic documents), control, common problem areas and costs assessment

This Practice Note sets out how to conduct a reasonable search for standard disclosure under CPR 31.7. It tackles core questions under the Civil Procedure Rules (CPR): ‘What is standard disclosure?’, ‘What counts as a document?’ and ‘What constitutes a reasonable search?’, addressing meaning, relevance, reasonableness and control by reference to the overriding principles. It also considers practical issues with back-up data, keyword searches and metadata. Business and Property Court claims This Practice Note does not cover the disclosure scheme operating in the Business and Property Courts. For guidance on that regime, see: Disclosure Scheme (Business & Property Courts)—overview. Claims issued on or after 1 October 2015 in the Business and Property Courts may fall within, and/or be governed by, one or both schemes under CPR PD 57AB: the shorter trials scheme and the flexible trials scheme. For more on these, see Practice Notes: Business and Property Courts—shorter trials scheme—Disclosure under the shorter trials scheme, and Business and Property Courts—flexible trials scheme—Disclosure under the flexible trials scheme. ...

Read More Right Arrow
PRACTICE NOTES
Specific disclosure under CPR 31.12: principles, privilege, confidentiality, ECHR balance and early disclosure (incl. procurement); CPR 31.14 inspection; PD 57AD/CPR 18 interactions (England and Wales)

This Practice Note This Practice Note examines how the courts approach specific disclosure under CPR 31.12, together with considerations under article 6(1) and article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR). It sets out the principles applied (including in procurement matters) and addresses: confidentiality; enhanced disclosure or train of enquiry material; documents cited in statements of case and witness statements; and compliance with an order for specific disclosure and/or specific inspection. The interaction with applications for further information under CPR 18 is also considered. Finally, it provides practical tips on specific disclosure. This Practice Note offers guidance on interpreting and applying the relevant CPR provisions. Depending on the court in which your case is proceeding, you may also wish to follow additional court-specific guidance noted below. The Practice Note considers the courts’ approach to specific disclosure under CPR 31.12 and should be read alongside the following Practice Notes: Specific disclosure Specific disclosure—making an application Note: this Practice Note does not...

Read More Right Arrow